Understanding Perjury Charges: Law, Penalties, & Defenses

The U.S. legal system is founded on the pursuit of truth. When an individual provides sworn testimony—whether in a courtroom, a deposition, or on a signed affidavit—they are placing the weight of their credibility, and the legal process itself, on their words. The act of intentionally compromising this trust is defined as perjury, a criminal offense that carries severe, felony-level penalties under both federal and state laws.

Facing a perjury charge is a profoundly serious matter, as it not only exposes an individual to imprisonment and heavy fines but also permanently damages one’s reputation and future prospects. It is critical for anyone involved in a legal proceeding to fully grasp what constitutes this crime and the complexities surrounding its prosecution.

The Core Elements of a Perjury Charge

For a prosecutor to secure a conviction for perjury, they must prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, that several specific elements were present at the time the false statement was made. These elements ensure that an honest mistake, confusion, or a lapse in memory is not wrongfully penalized.

• Under an Oath or Affirmation: The statement must have been made while the declarant was legally bound to tell the truth. This typically occurs in a court, grand jury, deposition, or on a document signed “under penalty of perjury” (such as a federal income tax return).
• The Statement Was False: The testimony or statement must be factually untrue. Opinions, interpretations of fact, or statements resulting from honest, albeit mistaken, belief are generally not considered perjury.
• Knowledge and Willfulness: The declarant must have known the statement was false at the time they made it and must have made the statement willfully, meaning they intended to deceive the tribunal. This element is what distinguishes perjury from simple mistake or confusion.
• Materiality: The false statement must relate to a “material” fact. A material fact is one that has a natural tendency to influence or be capable of influencing the decision or outcome of the proceeding, even if it did not actually do so.

Federal Laws Governing Perjury

In the United States, federal law primarily addresses perjury through three key statutes in Title 18 of the U.S. Code:

Statute	Focus	Key Distinction
18 U.S.C. § 1621	Perjury Generally (Broadly Applicable)	Applies to false statements under oath before legislative, administrative, or judicial bodies. Requires proof of a willfully false, material statement.
18 U.S.C. § 1623	False Declarations Before Court or Grand Jury (Specific)	Limited to false statements in federal court or grand jury proceedings. It simplifies proof by having a statutory recantation defense.
18 U.S.C. § 1622	Subornation of Perjury	Criminalizes inducing or procuring another person to commit perjury.

Penalties and Long-Term Consequences

Perjury is classified as a felony offense under federal law and in most U.S. states. The penalties are deliberately severe to underscore the crime’s impact on the rule of law.

• Imprisonment: A conviction under federal statutes (§ 1621 or § 1623) can result in a prison sentence of up to five years, along with significant fines.
• Enhanced Sentencing: The U.S. Sentencing Guidelines may apply an obstruction of justice enhancement (a two-level increase) to a defendant’s sentence for an underlying crime if they committed perjury during their trial or investigation.
• Aggravated Perjury: In some jurisdictions, if false testimony leads to the wrongful conviction and execution of another person, the perjurer may face an aggravated charge, potentially punishable by life imprisonment or death, depending on state law.

Common Defenses Against Perjury Charges

A successful defense against a charge of perjury hinges on disproving one of the essential elements of the crime. Since the burden of proof is on the prosecution, defense strategy often focuses on challenging the “willfulness” and “materiality” elements.

• Lack of Intent (Mistake of Fact): This is arguably the most common and powerful defense. The defendant can argue that they did not intentionally lie but were genuinely confused, misremembered the facts, misunderstood the question, or made an honest mistake. Since perjury requires willful intent to deceive, a lack of such intent negates a key element.
• Immateriality: The defense may argue that the false statement, even if intentional, had no bearing on the outcome of the case and was therefore not “material” to the proceeding as defined by law.
• Recantation (18 U.S.C. § 1623 only): For false declarations in a federal court or grand jury (§ 1623), a defendant may avoid conviction if they admit the falsity and correct the statement (recant) during the same proceeding, provided the false statement has not yet substantially affected the proceeding and the falsity has not already been exposed.

Summary: Navigating Perjury Allegations

Perjury is an attack on the integrity of the judicial process. Understanding the specific legal requirements for this charge is essential for anyone giving testimony.

1. Perjury is a felony requiring a statement to be false, material, and made willfully/knowingly under oath.
2. Federal law punishes perjury with up to five years in prison, but penalties can be enhanced if the act obstructs justice in an underlying criminal case.
3. A conviction leads to severe long-term consequences, including loss of professional licenses and permanent damage to credibility and reputation.
4. Primary defenses focus on proving a lack of criminal intent (mistake/confusion) or demonstrating that the false statement was not “material” to the legal proceeding.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q1: Is it perjury if I forget a detail while testifying?

No. Perjury requires the false statement to be made willfully, meaning you knew it was false at the time you said it and intended to deceive. A faulty memory, confusion, or honest mistake cannot form the basis of a perjury conviction.

Q2: Can I be charged with perjury for lying on a government form?

Yes, if the form includes language stating that you are signing “under penalty of perjury” (such as a federal tax return or certain immigration documents), a knowing, material falsehood can be prosecuted as perjury under 18 U.S.C. § 1621.

Q3: What is the difference between perjury and subornation of perjury?

Perjury is the act of a person lying under oath. Subornation of perjury (18 U.S.C. § 1622) is the crime of persuading, bribing, or otherwise inducing another person to commit perjury.

Q4: Does recanting a false statement protect me from charges?

It may. Under the federal statute 18 U.S.C. § 1623, a recantation is a defense if it is made in the same proceeding, before the false statement has substantially affected the proceeding, and before the falsity is officially established or detected. However, this defense is not mandatory under all laws.

Q5: What is the maximum federal prison sentence for a perjury conviction?

Under 18 U.S.C. § 1621 and § 1623, the maximum penalty for perjury is five years in federal prison and a fine.

***

perjury crime, lying under oath, false declaration, 18 U.S.C. § 1621, federal perjury penalty, defense to perjury charges, felony perjury, subornation of perjury, material false statement, perjury elements