Understanding Treason Charges in the United States

Treason is a unique offense within the American legal framework. It is the only crime expressly defined within the U.S. Constitution, a deliberate effort by the Framers to guard against the historic misuse of treason prosecutions by repressive governments to silence political opponents. Because of this explicit constitutional definition, treason against the United States is considered the most serious offense a person who owes allegiance to the country can commit.

This article provides an in-depth examination of federal treason charges, from their narrow constitutional origin to the stringent evidentiary requirements that make conviction exceedingly rare.

The Constitutional Definition: Article III, Section 3

The U.S. Constitution, in Article III, Section 3, Clause 1, precisely limits what constitutes treason. It states that:

“Treason against the United States, shall consist only in levying War against them, or in adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort.”

This definition intentionally confines the crime to two specific types of conduct:

1. Levying War Against the United States: This involves actively taking up arms against the government or assembling a body of men for a purpose treasonable in itself. Critically, a mere conspiracy to levy war is not enough; there must be an “actual assemblage of men for the purpose of executing a treasonable design”.
2. Adhering to their Enemies, Giving them Aid and Comfort: This involves having loyalty to an enemy of the U.S. and actively providing some form of support to that enemy. An “enemy” is a nation or group with whom the United States is officially at war.

The Critical Safeguard: The Two-Witness Rule

To further prevent political prosecutions, the Treason Clause establishes a unique and highly stringent evidentiary requirement. It explicitly states:

“No Person shall be convicted of Treason unless on the Testimony of two Witnesses to the same overt Act, or on Confession in open Court.”

This is often referred to as the Two-Witness Rule. Its purpose is to ensure that a conviction cannot rest on a single, potentially biased, or self-interested witness.

What Qualifies as an “Overt Act”?

An overt act is an action that manifests a treasonable intent, moving the “treasonable project… from the realm of thought into the realm of action”. The Supreme Court has clarified this requirement through key rulings, most notably during World War II:

• In Cramer v. United States (1945), the Court ruled that the overt act itself must be supported by two witnesses. It held that the act must actually give aid and comfort to the enemy, and the defendant’s intent to betray must be evident from the witnessed acts.
• However, in Haupt v. United States (1947), the Court upheld a conviction where the defendant’s actions—harboring his son, a German saboteur, and assisting him in obtaining employment—were otherwise “innocent” acts but, when taken in the context of the son’s mission, clearly constituted “aid in steps essential to his design for treason”. The Court held that the treasonable intent does not need two witnesses, but can be inferred from all circumstances surrounding the overt act.

The Severe Penalties for Treason

As a capital offense, the punishment for treason is one of the most severe under federal law. According to 18 U.S. Code § 2381, a person guilty of treason:

• Shall suffer death, or
• Shall be imprisoned not less than five years and fined not less than $10,000, and
• Shall be permanently incapable of holding any office under the United States.

Limitation on Punishment: Corruption of Blood

The Constitution also limits Congress’s power regarding the punishment of treason. Clause 2 of Article III, Section 3, states that “no Attainder of Treason shall work Corruption of Blood, or Forfeiture except during the Life of the Person attainted”.

Treason vs. Related Crimes: Espionage and Sedition

Though treason is the ultimate crime of betrayal, federal prosecutors rarely bring treason charges. Since 1954, only one person has been charged with treason against the United States (Adam Gadahn, who was killed before trial). The reason for this rarity is the constitutional bar of the two-witness rule, which is difficult to meet.

Instead, many acts that might seem treasonous are prosecuted under alternative federal statutes with lower evidentiary standards, most notably:

• Espionage: The act of spying or revealing government secrets to a foreign power. The famous case of Julius and Ethel Rosenberg, who disclosed atomic secrets to the Soviet Union, was prosecuted as conspiracy to commit espionage, not treason, because it did not require the two-witness rule.
• Sedition/Seditious Conspiracy: Involves a conspiracy or combination to oppose the authority of the government by force, or to hinder the execution of any law. Like espionage, it lacks the strict constitutional requirements of treason.

These related crimes allow for prosecution of national security threats without having to meet the exceptionally high burden of proof set forth in the Treason Clause.

Summary: Key Takeaways on Treason Charges

To summarize the complex nature of this constitutional charge:

1. Treason is the only crime defined directly in the U.S. Constitution, ensuring a narrow scope.
2. It is strictly limited to “levying war against” or “giving aid and comfort to” the enemies of the U.S..
3. A conviction requires the testimony of two witnesses to the same overt act, or a confession in open court.
4. The punishment includes death or lengthy imprisonment and disqualification from public office.
5. Acts of betrayal are more commonly prosecuted under statutes like Espionage or Sedition due to the difficulty of proving treason.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Treason, Treason Clause, U.S. Constitution, Article III Section 3, Levying War, Aid and Comfort to the Enemy, Overt Act, Two-Witness Rule, Federal Crime, Capital Offense, Espionage, Sedition, Treason Penalty, Treason conviction, Criminal Law, John Marshall, Aaron Burr, Cramer v. United States, Haupt v. United States, Allegiance