Understanding Copyright Ownership Exceptions
In copyright law, the general rule is that the person who physically creates an original work is considered the legal author and initial owner of the copyright. However, the “Work Made for Hire” (WMFH) doctrine is a crucial exception to this rule. Under WMFH, the individual who created the work is not the author; instead, the employer or the party who commissioned the work is considered the legal author and the initial copyright owner from the moment of creation. This distinction carries significant long-term implications for ownership, duration, and the right to terminate transfers.
The Two Statutory Categories of Work Made for Hire
The US Copyright Act of 1976 clearly defines the two distinct situations in which a work can be classified as WMFH. It is vital to understand which category applies, as the requirements for each are vastly different.
1. Works Prepared by an Employee Within the Scope of Employment
This is the most common and automatic form of WMFH. If an individual is classified as a legal employee, the work they create as part of their regular job duties is automatically owned by the employer. No written agreement explicitly stating “work made for hire” is required, though one is always advisable.
To determine if a creator is an “employee” for copyright purposes, courts apply the common law of agency principles, based on the landmark Supreme Court case, Community for Creative Non-Violence v. Reid (1989). Factors considered include:
- The skill required for the work.
- The source of the tools and instrumentalities.
- The location of the work.
- The duration of the relationship.
- Whether the hiring party provides employee benefits or pays taxes for the hired party.
- The hiring party’s right to control the manner and means of creation.
2. Specially Ordered or Commissioned Works
This category applies specifically to works created by an independent contractor or freelancer. For a commissioned work to qualify as WMFH, three stringent requirements must all be met:
- Written Agreement: The parties must expressly agree in a written instrument, signed by both, that the work will be considered a “work made for hire”.
- Statutory Category: The work must fall into one of the nine specific, narrow categories defined by the Copyright Act.
- Specially Commissioned: The work must be commissioned for a specific project, not simply a pre-existing piece purchased later.
The Nine Statutory Categories for Commissioned Works
If a commissioned work does not fit into one of these nine types, it cannot be a WMFH, regardless of what the contract says:
| Category | Definition / Example |
|---|---|
| Contribution to a Collective Work | An article in a magazine or encyclopedia. |
| Part of a Motion Picture or Audiovisual Work | Music or footage created for a film or video. |
| Translation | Converting a work from one language to another. |
| Supplementary Work | Forewords, afterwords, charts, or illustrations that assist another work. |
| Compilation | A work formed by collecting and assembling pre-existing materials. |
| Instructional Text | Literary, pictorial, or graphic works prepared for use in systematic instructional activities. |
| Test or Answer Material for a Test | Specific material related to assessments. |
| Atlas | A collection of maps. |
CAUTION: WMFH vs. Copyright Assignment
This is the most critical difference. If a work is a true WMFH, the initial owner (the hiring party) owns the copyright for the full term (95 years from publication or 120 years from creation). The original creator has no right to terminate the transfer.
If the work is not a WMFH and the creator simply transfers (assigns) the copyright to the hiring party, the creator (or their heirs) retains the statutory right to terminate that transfer after 35 years and reclaim the rights. Because WMFH status is often challenged, a robust independent contractor agreement should always include a “backup assignment” clause to ensure ownership, even if termination rights remain.
Summary: Key Takeaways for Businesses and Creators
- The status of an individual (employee versus independent contractor) is determined by the common law of agency, not simply the label on a contract.
- For works by independent contractors, the WMFH doctrine is extremely narrow, requiring both a clear written agreement and that the work fits into one of the nine statutory categories.
- In a WMFH scenario, the hiring party is considered the legal “author,” eliminating the creator’s statutory termination rights that apply to simple copyright assignments.
- When dealing with independent contractors, a contract should always include a WMFH clause for eligible works AND a backup copyright assignment clause to secure ownership regardless of the WMFH determination.
Post Card Summary: Work Made for Hire
The WMFH doctrine is an exception under US Copyright Law where the employer or commissioning party is deemed the initial copyright owner and statutory author. For employees, ownership is automatic if the work is within the scope of employment. For independent contractors, WMFH applies only if the work is one of nine specific types and is backed by a signed, express written agreement. This status is critical because it eliminates the author’s right to reclaim ownership through statutory termination rights.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: Can a non-qualifying commissioned work be made a “Work Made for Hire” if the contract says so?
A: No. For independent contractors, the work must fall into one of the nine specific categories in the Copyright Act. A contract cannot force a work outside those categories to be a WMFH. However, the contract should still include a copyright assignment clause to transfer ownership.
Q: What is the term of copyright protection for a WMFH?
A: The term is 95 years from the date of first publication or 120 years from the date of creation, whichever expires first. This is different from the life-plus-70-years term for other works.
Q: As an independent contractor, should I waive my “moral rights” in a WMFH agreement?
A: Waivers of moral rights (under 17 U.S. Code § 106A) are often requested by commissioning parties, as they allow the client to modify or adapt the work without needing the creator’s permission or attribution. A creator should negotiate their compensation to reflect the loss of these rights and portfolio use.
Q: If an employee creates a copyrighted work at home on their own time, is it WMFH?
A: Likely not. For an employee’s work to be WMFH, it must be created “within the scope of his or her employment,” which generally requires the work to be the kind the employee was hired to perform and occur substantially within authorized time/space limits. If it is truly outside the scope, the employee would retain the copyright.
* Disclaimer *
This post is for informational purposes only and is based on general principles of US Copyright Law. It does not constitute legal advice. The legal landscape of copyright, especially concerning the distinction between employee and independent contractor, is complex and varies by jurisdiction and specific facts. Always consult with a qualified Legal Expert for advice tailored to your individual situation. This content was generated with the assistance of an AI model.
Work Made for Hire, Copyright Law, Intellectual Property, US Copyright Act of 1976, Employee vs Independent Contractor, Scope of Employment, Specially Commissioned Work, Copyright Ownership, Termination Rights, Waiver of Moral Rights, Copyright Assignment, Collective Work, Audiovisual Work, Instructional Text, Compilation, Author, Hiring Party, Common Law of Agency, Written Agreement, Freelancer Contract
Please consult a qualified legal professional for any specific legal matters.