Categories: Court Info

Partial summary judgment

Meta Description: Understand the power and procedure of partial summary judgment in civil litigation. Learn how legal experts use this crucial motion to resolve parts of a case efficiently, saving time and costs.

Understanding Partial Summary Judgment: A Key Civil Procedure Tool

In the complex world of civil litigation, efficiency is paramount. Not every dispute requires a full-blown trial. This is where the motion for Summary Judgment comes into play, a powerful tool designed to resolve cases—or parts of cases—where there are no genuine disputes of material fact.

Specifically, a partial summary judgment motion is a strategic maneuver that allows the court to rule on some, but not all, of the claims or defenses involved in a lawsuit. This article, written in a professional and calm tone for legal professionals and litigants, will break down what partial summary judgment is, its requirements, and its significant impact on the litigation process.

What is Partial Summary Judgment?

Summary judgment, in general, is a ruling handed down by the court without a full trial. It states that, based on the evidence presented in discovery (depositions, documents, affidavits), one party is entitled to judgment as a matter of law. A partial summary judgment (PSJ) applies this concept to a specific slice of the overall case, rather than the entire lawsuit.

💡 Legal Expert Tip: PSJ is strategically useful for isolating a specific claim (e.g., breach of contract liability) from complex issues (e.g., the amount of damages). By settling liability early, the scope of the remaining trial (on damages only) is drastically narrowed, saving resources.

The Difference Between Full and Partial Summary Judgment

Full Summary Judgment: If granted, the entire case is resolved, and a final judgment is entered in favor of the moving party.
Partial Summary Judgment (PSJ): If granted, only specific claims, defenses, or issues (like liability or one of multiple causes of action) are resolved. The rest of the case proceeds to trial.

The Procedural Requirements for PSJ

The standard for granting a PSJ motion is identical to a full summary judgment motion. The moving party must demonstrate two critical elements:

No Genuine Dispute of Material Fact: The evidence shows that there are no disagreements between the parties over the facts that matter to the legal outcome of the specific claim being addressed.
Entitled to Judgment as a Matter of Law: Based on the undisputed material facts, the relevant law clearly dictates that the moving party must win on that specific claim or issue.

🛑 Caution Regarding Evidence

Courts view the evidence in the light most favorable to the non-moving party. If there is any credible evidence creating a factual dispute, the motion—even a partial one—will likely be denied because the jury must resolve that dispute.

Key Documents in a PSJ Motion

Document	Purpose
Motion	Formal request for the court to rule on the specific issue/claim.
Statement of Undisputed Facts	A list of facts the moving party asserts are not disputed, with citations to evidence.
Supporting Memorandum/Brief	Legal argument explaining why the law entitles the party to judgment on the specific facts.
Exhibits (Evidence)	Affidavits, deposition excerpts, and documents that verify the undisputed facts.

Strategic Implications of Granting PSJ

A successful PSJ motion has significant strategic benefits for the litigation:

Narrows the Scope of Trial: If liability is resolved, the trial only needs to focus on damages. This saves significant time, effort, and money during the pre-trial and trial phases.
Promotes Settlement: A partial ruling against one party can drastically shift the leverage in settlement negotiations. The losing party may be more inclined to settle the remaining issues to avoid further risk.
Definitive Resolution of Claims: It eliminates frivolous or unsupported claims or defenses early, focusing the court and the parties on the genuine core of the dispute.

Case Example: Resolving Contract Disputes

In a lawsuit involving a breach of contract (Claim 1) and a claim for tortious interference (Claim 2), the defendant might file a PSJ motion on Claim 2. If the court finds there is no evidence to support the ‘malice’ element of tortious interference, the court grants PSJ on Claim 2. Claim 1 (breach of contract) then proceeds to trial or further settlement discussions, but the complex tort claim is removed from the case, simplifying all remaining proceedings.

Summary: The Power of Targeted Resolution

Partial summary judgment is a vital mechanism within legal procedures (

Legal Procedures

). It allows for the targeted resolution of specific legal issues (

Legal Procedures – Filing & Motions

) without the need for a full trial on every component of the case (

Legal Procedures – Trials & Hearings

). For litigants and legal experts alike, understanding when and how to deploy this motion is critical to achieving a streamlined and favorable outcome.

PSJ resolves some claims/issues, leaving others for trial, based on undisputed material facts and law.
It serves to significantly narrow the scope of the trial and subsequent proceedings.
The standard is the same as full summary judgment: no genuine dispute of material fact.
Successful PSJ motions often lead to more efficient settlements of the remaining dispute.

Post Summary Card

Partial summary judgment is a strategic filing and motion (

Legal Procedures – Filing & Motions

) that targets specific claims or issues within a lawsuit. It is a powerful pre-trial mechanism that ensures a more efficient resolution by eliminating claims lacking a factual dispute, thus streamlining the remaining matters for trial or encouraging settlement.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: Can a Partial Summary Judgment be appealed immediately?

A: Generally, no. A PSJ ruling is an interlocutory order, meaning it is not a final judgment. It usually must wait until the entire case is concluded (after the final trial) before it can be appealed.

Q: What happens if a party loses a PSJ motion?

A: If a party’s motion is denied, that claim or issue simply proceeds along with the rest of the case to trial. The ruling does not prevent the party from arguing the issue at trial.

Q: Can a PSJ motion be used to resolve the issue of damages?

A: Yes. If the amount of damages is undisputed (e.g., a simple calculation based on a liquidated clause), but liability is contested, a party could move for PSJ on the damages amount, leaving only liability for trial.

Q: Does a PSJ ruling carry the same weight as a jury verdict?

A: Yes, on the issues it resolves. The judgment granted via PSJ is binding and conclusive on the specific claims or defenses it addresses, operating just as a verdict would on those issues.

Disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. While this article was generated with the assistance of an AI, all legal concepts, terms (like Legal Expert, Financial Expert, etc.), and procedural information have been carefully reviewed for compliance with legal portal safety and accuracy standards. Consult a qualified Legal Expert for advice on your specific situation.

Partial summary judgment, civil procedure, filing & motions, trials & hearings, appellate briefs, contract law, tort, legal resources, civil cases, legal procedures

geunim