Alabama Reckless Driving: How to Withdraw a Guilty Plea

Facing a criminal charge like reckless driving in Alabama is serious. This offense is classified as a misdemeanor, not merely a traffic ticket, and a conviction carries long-term consequences, including a permanent criminal record, potential jail time, and license suspension. Many individuals, believing they have no other choice or under pressure, enter a guilty plea only to later experience remorse or realize they made a decision without full information.

For those who have pleaded guilty—whether through a formal plea agreement or a “blind plea”—but now wish to challenge the conviction, the law provides a narrow window and strict procedure to withdraw the plea. Understanding the Alabama Rules of Criminal Procedure, particularly the stringent standards for filing a Motion to Withdraw Guilty Plea, is absolutely vital to the success of your case. The legal timing of your motion will significantly dictate the burden of proof you must meet.

The Gravity of an Alabama Reckless Driving Conviction

Alabama Code § 32-5A-190 defines reckless driving as operating a vehicle with willful or wanton disregard for the safety of persons or property. The penalties for this misdemeanor are considerable:

Reckless Driving Penalties in Alabama

Offense Level	Jail Time	Fine Range
First Conviction	5 to 90 days	$25 to $500
Second/Subsequent	10 days to 6 months	$50 to $500

In addition to these direct criminal penalties, the court can suspend your driver’s license for up to six months. Given the far-reaching impact on employment, insurance, and professional licensing, a reckless driving plea should never be taken lightly.

Alabama’s Rules for Withdrawing a Guilty Plea

The procedure for withdrawing a guilty plea in Alabama is governed by the Alabama Rules of Criminal Procedure, particularly the principles articulated in Rule 14. This rule creates a critical distinction based on the timing of your request:

1. Before Sentencing (The “Fair and Just Reason” Standard)

If you file a motion to withdraw your guilty plea before the judge has imposed a sentence, your motion is more likely to be successful. While not an automatic right, the defendant must generally show a “fair and just reason” for the withdrawal. This is the most opportune time to reverse a plea decision.

2. After Sentencing (The “Manifest Injustice” Standard)

Once the judge has accepted the plea and handed down the sentence, withdrawing the plea becomes exceptionally difficult. The court will only allow withdrawal if it is deemed necessary to correct a “manifest injustice”. This high standard requires you to prove that the original plea process was fundamentally flawed. Furthermore, under Alabama law, you typically have a limited 30-day window after sentencing to file a motion to withdraw the plea.

Critical Grounds for a Successful Motion to Withdraw

To satisfy the court’s requirements for a plea withdrawal—especially the “manifest injustice” standard—the motion must be based on a legally sufficient reason. Simply changing your mind is not enough. Common valid grounds include:

• Lack of Understanding: The defendant did not fully understand the nature of the charge, the consequences of the guilty plea (such as deportation for non-citizens), or the constitutional rights they were waiving (like the right to a jury trial).
• Coercion or Duress: The plea was entered due to threats, coercion, or misrepresentation by the prosecution or other parties.
• Ineffective Assistance of Counsel: While complex, a claim that the defendant’s previous legal counsel provided incorrect advice that induced the plea can be a valid ground.
• New, Compelling Evidence: The discovery of consequential new evidence relating to the case that proves innocence or significantly weakens the prosecution’s case can be compelling.
• Broken Plea Agreement: A violation of the negotiated plea deal by the prosecution, such as failing to drop promised charges or recommending a harsher sentence than agreed upon.

Summary: Three Steps to Challenging a Guilty Plea

1. File a Motion: A formal Motion to Withdraw Guilty Plea must be filed with the court (often the Circuit Court if an indictment was involved) stating the specific legal grounds for the withdrawal.
2. Meet the Standard: Be prepared to meet the necessary burden of proof—a “fair and just reason” before sentencing, or the higher standard of “manifest injustice” after sentencing.
3. Revert to Status Quo: If the motion is granted, your case typically reverts to its status before the plea was entered. This means the original reckless driving charge and indictment are reinstated, and the case will proceed to trial or further negotiation.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: What Alabama Rule governs the withdrawal of a guilty plea?

The procedure is primarily governed by the principles found in the Alabama Rules of Criminal Procedure, specifically concerning the plea process and motions after sentencing, such as the principles of Rule 14.

Q: Can I withdraw my plea if the judge gives me a harsher sentence than expected?

If you entered a plea deal and the judge rejects the agreement, you must be given the opportunity to withdraw the plea. If the judge accepts the agreement but imposes a harsher sentence than recommended (in a non-binding recommendation), withdrawal is more difficult and relies on showing “manifest injustice”.

Q: What does it mean if the original charge was via “indictment”?

An indictment means the charge was brought in the Circuit Court after a grand jury review. Withdrawing a plea to an indicted charge means the case reverts to a Circuit Court proceeding, making the legal process more formal and complex than a standard traffic citation case.

Q: How long do I have to file a Motion to Withdraw Guilty Plea in Alabama?

To withdraw a plea after sentencing, you typically have a 30-day window to file a motion. It is best to file the motion before sentencing, as the legal standard is lower and the likelihood of success is higher.

The decision to withdraw a guilty plea for an Alabama reckless driving charge should be made with immediate and careful consideration of the legal standards and procedural deadlines. By understanding the distinction between the “fair and just reason” standard and the “manifest injustice” standard, you can approach the court with a fully prepared and legally grounded Motion to Withdraw Guilty Plea.

Alabama Reckless driving, withdraw guilty plea, motion to withdraw guilty plea, Rule 14.3 Ala. R. Crim. P., before sentencing, after sentencing, manifest injustice, misdemeanor criminal offense, criminal procedure, plea agreement, plea withdrawal, indictment, circuit court, criminal, DUI, motions, appeals, legal procedures, case law