Categories: Court Info

Alabama DWI Jury Selection & Restitution Explained

Meta Description: A Professional Guide to Navigating the Alabama DUI/DWI Legal System, from the intricate process of jury selection (voir dire and challenges) to the critical role and enforcement of criminal restitution for victims.

Navigating a Driving While Intoxicated (DWI), commonly referred to as Driving Under the Influence (DUI), charge in Alabama can be one of the most stressful legal challenges an individual can face. The process is not limited to fines and jail time; it involves intricate procedural steps like jury selection and serious financial penalties such as court-ordered restitution if damages occurred. Understanding the legal landscape, particularly the crucial trial phase and potential financial liabilities, is paramount to securing a fair outcome.

Understanding Alabama’s DWI/DUI Legal Framework

Alabama law defines DUI under Section 32-5A-191. A person can be convicted of DUI in one of two ways:

The “Per Se” Violation: Having a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) of .08 percent or more.
The “Under the Influence” Violation: Being under the influence of alcohol, drugs, or any impairing substance to an extent that renders the individual incapable of safely driving a vehicle.

Crucially, Alabama utilizes the concept of “actual physical control.” This means a motorist can be arrested and charged with DUI even if the vehicle is not in motion, if they are deemed capable of setting the car in motion while intoxicated.

Key Distinctions in Alabama DUI Offenses

DUI Type	Proof Requirement	Basis in Law
Per Se	Evidentiary test (e.g., breath or blood) showing BAC ≥ .08%.	BAC alone establishes a presumption of impairment.
Under the Influence	Circumstantial evidence (e.g., field sobriety tests, officer observation).	Driver’s ability to operate the vehicle safely was impaired.

The Critical Phase of Jury Selection (Voir Dire)

For a DUI charge that goes to trial, the jury selection process, known as voir dire (meaning “to speak the truth”), is a pivotal step. The goal is to select an impartial panel of the defendant’s peers to decide the case.

How the Jury Pool is Assembled

Potential jurors are randomly selected from a master list, typically drawn from voter registration lists and driver’s license/state ID databases. Once assembled at the courthouse, a multi-step screening begins where the judge, prosecution, and defense counsel question them to assess suitability.

Jury Challenges: Striking the Panel

The parties use challenges to remove potential jurors they believe cannot be fair:

Challenge for Cause: Used when a legal reason exists to believe a juror is biased or prejudiced. These challenges are generally unlimited in number but require a clear explanation and the judge’s agreement.
Peremptory Challenge: Allows a party to exclude a juror without providing a reason. The number is limited and varies based on the severity of the case (misdemeanor vs. felony). However, these challenges cannot be used based on race, ethnicity, or sex.

Legal Expert’s Tip: The Power of Voir Dire

The jury selection phase is the first opportunity for a criminal defense Legal Expert to shape the trial’s outcome. An experienced Legal Expert is trained to ask strategic questions to uncover hidden biases, ensuring the final jury is as impartial as possible and increasing the chances of the prosecution meeting its burden of proof beyond a reasonable doubt.

Restitution: The Financial Liability in Criminal DWI Cases

If a DWI offense results in an accident, injury, or property damage, the defendant will likely face an order for criminal restitution. Under Alabama Code § 15-18-67, when a defendant is convicted of a crime that results in pecuniary damages or loss to a victim, the court is obligated to hold a hearing to determine the amount of restitution owed. This is mandatory and is ordered in addition to any other sentence, such as fines, jail time, or license suspension.

Key Aspects of Alabama Restitution

Pecuniary Damages: Restitution covers “pecuniary damages or loss,” which generally means tangible financial losses like medical bills, lost wages, and property damage. It typically does not include damages for pain and suffering.
Ability to Pay: The court must consider the defendant’s financial resources and ability to pay, often setting up installment plans as a condition of probation.
Consequence of Non-Payment: Failure to pay court-ordered restitution can lead to serious consequences, including a violation of probation and potential jail time.
Separate from Civil Lawsuit: A restitution order in the criminal case does not prevent the victim from pursuing a separate civil lawsuit for further damages.

Case Example: Mandatory Restitution Hearing

A defendant, “Mr. D,” was convicted of DUI following an accident where he struck another vehicle, resulting in $12,000 in repair costs and $3,000 in missed work for the victim, “Ms. V.” Even if the judge imposes probation and no jail time, Alabama law mandates a separate restitution hearing. At this hearing, the prosecution must present evidence of Ms. V’s losses. The judge will then issue an order requiring Mr. D to pay $15,000 in restitution to the circuit clerk, often setting a monthly payment schedule based on Mr. D’s income and assets, making it a critical financial obligation of his sentence.

Summary: Key Takeaways

Alabama DUI cases can proceed with either a BAC over the legal limit (Per Se) or evidence of impairment (Under the Influence), and the concept of “actual physical control” is key.
Jury selection in a DWI trial involves the voir dire process, where both sides use “challenges for cause” and limited “peremptory challenges” to seat an impartial jury (12 members for a felony, 6 for a misdemeanor).
The defense Legal Expert’s strategic questioning during jury selection is vital to filter out biases and ensure a fair trial.
When a DWI offense causes financial harm, Alabama Code § 15-18-67 makes criminal restitution to the victim mandatory, covering pecuniary losses such as medical bills and property damage.
Restitution is a criminal penalty separate from civil liability, and failure to pay it can result in a violation of probation or incarceration.

Post-Conviction Card Summary

Alabama DWI: Jury, Trial, and Financial Obligation

Jury Selection: Focus is on eliminating bias via voir dire and challenges. A meticulous defense is essential here.
DWI Conviction: Can be based on chemical test results or observed impairment.
Restitution: A mandatory, separate sentencing obligation for victim’s financial losses (pecuniary damages).

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: How many jurors are required for an Alabama DWI trial?

A: For a misdemeanor DUI charge, the jury typically consists of 6 members. For a felony DUI charge, which is common in cases involving serious injury or a habitual offender, the final jury consists of 12 members.

Q: Can I refuse to pay restitution in an Alabama DUI case?

A: No. If pecuniary damages occurred, the court shall order restitution under Alabama Code § 15-18-67. Failure to comply is a violation of a court order and can lead to probation revocation, fines, and/or further incarceration.

Q: What is the difference between a “challenge for cause” and a “peremptory challenge” in jury selection?

A: A challenge for cause is the removal of a juror for a legally justifiable reason (e.g., demonstrated bias) and is unlimited. A peremptory challenge is the removal of a juror without needing to state a reason, but the number of these challenges is strictly limited by law.

Q: Does paying criminal restitution prevent the victim from filing a civil lawsuit?

A: No. A criminal restitution order is a compensatory measure for the victim’s financial loss, but it does not prevent the victim from pursuing a separate civil lawsuit for additional damages, such as pain and suffering, which are often not covered by criminal restitution.

Disclaimer: Important Legal Notice

This blog post was generated by an Artificial Intelligence and is for informational purposes only. It is intended to provide a general overview of the Alabama legal concepts of DUI/DWI procedure, jury selection, and restitution. The information presented here does not, and is not intended to, constitute legal advice. Laws, including statutes and case law, are constantly changing, and your individual situation is unique. Always consult with a qualified criminal defense Legal Expert licensed in your jurisdiction to discuss the specifics of your case. No attorney-client relationship is formed by reading this content.

Protect your rights and your future. Seek professional legal counsel today.

Alabama DWI, Alabama DUI, jury selection, voir dire, peremptory challenge, Alabama criminal case, restitution, victim, pecuniary damages, DUI trial, DUI procedure, sentencing, probation, criminal defense, Alabama law, court process, challenge for cause, driver’s license, BAC, actual physical control

geunim